It Was a Dark and Stormy Night (and I Regret Nothing)

It Was a Dark and Stormy Night (and I Regret Nothing)

I started this story years ago as a joke, got three paragraphs in, and put it in a drawer. It felt too easy. Nobody needs a parody of bad writing when there’s so much of the real thing around.

Then I kept reading. Contest entries, query letters, the first pages of books with shiny covers and blurbs from people I admire. Weather openings. Mirror scenes. Characters who “hiss” lines with no s in them. Villains who explain everything right before the hero escapes. The rules hadn’t gone anywhere. Writers had just stopped knowing why they were there.

So I came back to finish it. I’m going to break every rule I can think of, on purpose, and I’ll step in along the way to tell you which one I broke and why I’m not sorry. If it works, you’ll see the difference between a rule broken by accident and one broken for a reason. If it doesn’t, at least the dog gets a line.

* * *

It was a dark and stormy night. The rain fell in sheets, the wind howled like a wounded animal, and somewhere in the distance a lone dog barked, because of course it did.

Rule 1: Don’t open with the weather. I see this one every week, usually as two paragraphs of fog before anybody has a name. I did it in one sentence and gave the dog a punch line, because here the weather has a job: it tells you this is a bad novel and invites you to relax. Remember that you relaxed.

Detective Mara Quill woke with a start, drenched in sweat, from a dream in which she was falling. She stumbled to the bathroom mirror and regarded herself. Her emerald eyes, flecked with gold, stared back from beneath a tumble of auburn hair. At thirty-nine, she was still beautiful, though the scar on her left cheek, a souvenir from the Calloway case, told a story she never discussed.

Rules 2 and 3: Don’t open with a character waking up, especially from a dream, and don’t describe your hero by parking her in front of a mirror. I’ve read both on the same first page more times than I can count, and I count. Here the dream is a seed I’ll dig up at the end. The mirror, and that “still beautiful,” is a fingerprint. Somebody vain wrote this paragraph. Keep that in mind.

Same old Mara, she thought bitterly. Same old ghosts.

She poured two fingers of whiskey, then a third, then gave up on the fingers altogether. Her partner, Danny, had been dead for three years, and she blamed herself. This was, after all, her last case before retirement.

Rule 4: Avoid stock characters and stock backstory. The whiskey, the dead partner, the last case before retirement: I didn’t invent a thing. I just went shopping in the aisle every crime writer walks down. Hold on to the receipt; Mara’s going to read it back to you.

Suddenly, the door burst open.

Rule 5: Never use “suddenly.” It announces a surprise instead of creating one. When a door has to tell you it’s sudden, the scene is staged. This one is. Literally.

“You have to help me!” cried a mysterious stranger in a trench coat. His face was hidden in shadow. “You’re the only one who can!”

“Why me?” she asked wearily.

“Because,” he said ominously, “you are the Chosen One.”

“I’m a homicide detective.”

“That too.”

Rule 6: Use “said.” Skip the adverbs, the said-bookisms, and the exclamation points. In five lines I’ve given you cried, asked wearily, and said ominously, and I’m just getting warm. The volume is up on purpose. You’re supposed to think whoever wrote this was lazy.

Rule 7: Don’t borrow tropes from the wrong genre. A Chosen One in a police procedural is a pressure valve, and Mara’s deadpan answer is me winking at you across the page: yes, I know, and so does she. That wink buys me your trust for the next mess.

Meanwhile, in the Mind of the Stranger

The stranger, whose name was Edwin Pell, feared she would refuse. He had rehearsed this moment for weeks, and his hands trembled inside his pockets. He did not know that, across town, the killer was already smiling.

Little did either of them know that the body at Hemlock Press had been dead for six hours, or that the cause of death was a fountain pen, or that the pen had been engraved with a single word: Darling.

Rules 8 and 9: Don’t head-hop, and don’t foreshadow with “little did they know.” Most head-hopping I see today happens because the writer forgot whose scene it was. I’m doing it to hand you a clue (those trembling hands) and point you somewhere else in the same breath (“the killer was already smiling”). Then “little did they know” delivers the weapon and one engraved word: Darling. As in “kill your darlings.” Somebody here couldn’t.

The Part Where I Explain Everything

Here, dear reader, is some necessary background. Hemlock Press was founded in 1952 by Augustus Hemlock, whose family had run the publishing trade for four generations, and whose rivalry with the neighboring firm of Strand & Daughters had, by all accounts, begun over a disputed semicolon. The building had eleven floors, a basement of rare manuscripts, and a editor-in-chief named Vivian Rook, who had been found dead in the Reference Room.

(Yes, I know. Hold on.)

Rules 10 and 11: Don’t info-dump, don’t call anyone “dear reader,” and don’t break the fourth wall. I just did all three, and so does half the fantasy I’ve read this year, maps included. But look at what’s buried in that paragraph of semicolons and floor counts: an editor-in-chief, found dead. The motive is hiding under the trivia, which is the one place nobody looks. (I left the typo in, too. An editor would have caught it. That’s sort of the point.)

The Scene of the Crime

Mara arrived at dawn. The storm had broken, and a pale sun crept over the rooftops. The body lay on the library floor, one hand outstretched toward a bookshelf, the other clutching a crumpled note.

“Who would do such a thing?” whispered the young officer, shaking.

“Someone,” Mara muttered darkly, “who has read too many books.”

She stopped. She looked at the rain-streaked window, the dramatic shaft of light, the convenient note, the engraved pen. She looked at the stranger, who had followed her inside and was now standing, inexplicably, in the shadows.

“This is too perfect,” she said.

The hinge: This is the line every broken rule has been waiting for. Up to now the story has been committing clichés. From here on, Mara reads them as evidence. That’s the whole trick. Without a hinge, a broken rule is just a mistake. With one, it’s a setup.

“Perfect?” he stammered.

“Every detail is a cliché. The storm. The whiskey. The mysterious stranger. A murder weapon with a message on it.” She turned slowly. “Real crime scenes are messy, Mr. Pell. Nobody investigates a murder that reads like a bad novel. They roll their eyes and go to lunch. That’s the point.”

Edwin Pell went pale. “I don’t know what you mean.”

“You do. You wrote the opening. A killer who wants to be ignored doesn’t hide the crime. He buries it in so many tired conventions that no one takes it seriously.” She held up the pen. “Vivian Rook was going to cut your manuscript. All four hundred pages of it. She called it derivative.”

He lunged. She sidestepped. The young officer, to his credit, tackled him in the doorway.

And Then She Woke Up

Mara sat bolt upright in bed. Sunlight streamed through the curtains. Birds sang. It had all been a dream.

Then her phone rang. It was the precinct. There was a body at Hemlock Press.

Rule 12: Never end with “it was all a dream.” It’s the cheapest exit in fiction, and I still find it in manuscripts that should know better. Here it isn’t an exit; it’s a loop. Mara rehearsed the case in her sleep, and the phone call starts the real one.

Why I Came Back to Finish This (Yes, Really)

I didn’t finish this story to make fun of anyone. I finished it because the rules of fiction keep getting broken by people who never learned what they were for. A rule isn’t a law. It’s a warning label left by every reader who ever put a book down. Break it by accident, and the reader feels the mess without knowing why. Break it on purpose, and the reader feels the mess, then finds out it was a clue.

Every rule I broke above does a job. The weather sets the trap. The adverbs make the manuscript look lazy. The mirror, the info dump, and the head-hopping are the killer’s fingerprints, because he’s the one “writing” the scene. And the dream ending earns its keep by refusing to end.

So here’s my ask the next time you’re tempted. Learn the rule. Learn why it’s there. Then, if you still want to break it, make it pay rent. A cliché used by accident is a flaw. A cliché used on purpose is a tool.

Now, if you’ll excuse me, my phone’s ringing. It’s the precinct. Somebody just opened a novel with the weather.

Teaching Guide: Breaking the Rules on Purpose

This guide turns the story above into a lesson for writers. The story breaks a dozen of the most familiar rules of fiction, and every break is load-bearing: remove one and the mystery gets weaker. The goal isn’t to teach writers to ignore the rules. It’s to show them how to tell a deliberate break from an accidental one.

How to Use This Piece

  1. First read: Have writers read the story cold, skipping the indented asides, and mark every place that makes them wince.
  2. Second read: Explain the twist’s logic (the killer “wrote” the opening), then have them reread with the asides. Ask which winces turned into clues.
  3. Debrief: Walk through the Rule Key below, then apply the four-question test and the discussion questions.
  4. Practice: Assign one or more of the exercises.

The Rule Key

Each numbered aside in the story corresponds to a row below.

The RuleWhere It’s BrokenThe Job It Does Here
1. Don’t open with the weather.“It was a dark and stormy night.”Signals “bad novel” on line one. The reader relaxes into a familiar groove, which is exactly where the killer wants them.
2. Don’t open with a character waking from a dream.“woke with a start, drenched in sweat, from a dream”Plants the dream motif the ending pays off, so the opening and closing mirror each other.
3. Don’t describe a character through a mirror.“She stumbled to the bathroom mirror and regarded herself.”Reads as amateur vanity (“still beautiful”), the first fingerprint of a writer in love with his own prose.
4. Avoid stock characters and stock backstory.The whiskey, the dead partner, the last case before retirementBuilds the inventory of clichés Mara will later list out loud as evidence.
5. Never use “suddenly.”“Suddenly, the door burst open.”Announces a surprise instead of creating one, which flags the scene as staged. And it was.
6. Use “said”; skip adverbs, said-bookisms, and exclamation points.“cried,” “asked wearily,” “said ominously,” “muttered darkly,” “stammered”Turns the volume up until the prose sounds overwrought, building the false sense of a lazy manuscript.
7. Don’t borrow tropes from the wrong genre.“You are the Chosen One.”A pressure valve. Mara’s deadpan reply tells the reader the author is in on the joke, which buys trust for everything that follows.
8. Don’t head-hop.“Meanwhile, in the Mind of the Stranger”Shows Pell’s fear directly. His trembling hands are a fair-play clue, while “the killer was already smiling” points the reader elsewhere.
9. Don’t foreshadow with “little did they know.”“Little did either of them know”Delivers the weapon and the word “Darling” (as in “kill your darlings”), quietly pointing at a writer whose work was cut.
10. Don’t info-dump, and don’t address the reader.“Here, dear reader, is some necessary background.”Hides the motive in plain sight: the editor, Vivian Rook, is buried in trivia about semicolons and floor counts.
11. Don’t break the fourth wall.“(Yes, I know. Hold on.)”The narrator’s wink. It reassures the reader that the mess is intentional, so they keep reading instead of quitting.
12. Never end with “it was all a dream.”“It had all been a dream.”Turns the ending into a loop rather than a cheat. The dream becomes a rehearsal, and the phone call starts the real case.

The hinge. All twelve breaks depend on one moment: Mara’s line “This is too perfect.” That’s where the story stops committing clichés and starts reading them as evidence. Without a hinge, a broken rule is just a mistake. With one, it’s a setup.

The Four-Question Test

Before breaking a rule in their own work, writers can ask:

  1. Do I know the rule and why it exists? Name the problem it prevents: boredom, confusion, distance, or cheating the reader.
  2. Is the break visibly on purpose? The reader should sense intent through a wink, a pattern, or a payoff.
  3. Does it pay off? Every break in this story returns later as a clue, a joke, or a structural echo.
  4. Would following the rule make this piece weaker? If not, follow the rule.

Discussion Questions

  • Where did you first suspect the bad writing was deliberate? What tipped you off?
  • Which broken rule does the most work in the story? Which could be cut without losing anything?
  • The essay claims the dream ending “earns its keep.” Do you agree? What would make it a cheat instead?
  • How does humor (the Chosen One, the disputed semicolon, “Yes, I know”) change a reader’s tolerance for broken rules?
  • The author steps in a dozen times to explain. Does the commentary help the story or hurt it? When should a writer explain, and when should the page speak for itself?
  • Pick a rule in your own genre that readers expect you to follow. What would it take to break it and be forgiven?

Exercises

  1. Play it straight. Rewrite the story’s first two paragraphs following every rule. Then compare: what did the clichéd version do that the clean version can’t?
  2. One rule, full payoff. Write a 300-word scene that breaks a single rule on purpose and pays it off before the scene ends.
  3. Find the hinge. Take a passage from your own draft that bends a rule, and write the one line or moment that tells the reader it was intentional.
  4. Accident or tool? Trade a page of work in progress with a partner. Each of you marks every broken rule and labels it “accident” or “tool,” then defends the labels.

Oh, and before you go: please share this post. Invite your friends. Like it, subscribe to it, ring the little bell, tattoo the link somewhere tasteful. My publicist (a ficus named Gerald) tells me this is how “building a platform” works, and I’ve learned never to argue with a ficus.

Sharing accomplishes two things. A: We all learn something. B: More people learn of me, which, according to a marketing seminar I attended in a hotel ballroom that smelled of carpet glue and quiet despair, is the same thing as selling books.

Picture it. Suddenly (yes, suddenly; I’ve earned one), through the swirling fog of a dream, a thousand strangers sit bolt upright in bed, drenched in sweat, and whisper breathlessly, “Who is this author with the impeccable sense of humor?” They stumble to the bathroom mirror. Their eyes, flecked with gold, widen with recognition. They reach for their phones. They click Share.

Or, and I want to be transparent here, it’s three in the morning, I have a wicked case of insomnia, and the characters in my most recent novel have stopped speaking to me. They’ve formed a union. Their first demand is that I stop writing blog posts and get back to chapter nineteen. Their second demand is better weather.

So share it. Do it for the craft. Do it for literature. Do it for my characters, who are, at this very moment, standing in the shadows of my office, inexplicably, in trench coats.

It was a dark and stormy night. I regret nothing. My latest published novel…


Discover more from TheTimeDok

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply